Can I Get a Legal Separation or an Annulment Instead of a Divorce in North Carolina?

When a marriage reaches a point where spouses no longer wish to continue their relationship, they may consider ending their marriage. In North Carolina, couples have several options besides divorce, including legal separation and annulment. Understanding the differences between these options and how they are governed by state law is important if you want to make informed decisions. The family law attorneys at Epperson Law Group are here to help.

Legal separation in North Carolina

Legal separation in North Carolina is often a step couples take before deciding whether to divorce. It provides a way for spouses to live apart while still being legally married, offering them time and space to consider their future. Unlike divorce, legal separation does not dissolve the marriage but allows couples to formalize certain arrangements, such as property division and child custody.

What is legal separation?

In North Carolina, legal separation occurs when a married couple lives separately and apart with the intention of ending the marital relationship. This separation must be voluntary and without cohabitation. While the state does not require a formal legal process to be considered separated, couples often enter into a separation agreement, which is a legally binding contract that outlines the terms of their separation.

A separation agreement can cover a variety of issues, including:

• Property division: How marital assets and debts will be divided between the spouses.
• Child custody and visitation: The arrangement for the care and visitation of any children involved.
• Spousal support: Whether one spouse will provide financial support to the other during the separation.

Benefits of legal separation

Legal separation offers several advantages, particularly for couples who are unsure about pursuing a divorce:

• Time to reconsider: Legal separation allows couples to live apart and evaluate their relationship without the finality of divorce. This can be an important period for reflection and decision-making.
• Maintenance of benefits: Some couples choose legal separation to maintain certain benefits, such as health insurance, that might be lost in a divorce. This is especially important when one spouse relies on another for insurance coverage.
• Religious or moral considerations: For some couples, divorce may be against their religious or moral beliefs. Legal separation provides a way to live apart while still adhering to those beliefs.

Legal separation and divorce

In North Carolina, legal separation is often a precursor to divorce. The state requires that spouses live separately and apart for at least one year to file for divorce. During this time, they must not cohabitate. A separation agreement can make this period more manageable by clearly defining the terms of the separation.

However, it’s important to note that legal separation does not automatically lead to divorce. If the couple reconciles during the separation period, they can resume marriage without legal consequences. On the other hand, if they decide to divorce after the separation period, the terms outlined in the separation agreement may be used as a basis for the divorce settlement.

Annulment in North Carolina

Annulment is another legal option available to couples in North Carolina. Unlike divorce, which ends a valid marriage, annulment declares that the marriage was never legally valid in the first place. This distinction means that, in the eyes of the law, an annulled marriage is treated as though it never existed.

Grounds for annulment

In North Carolina, annulments are granted under specific circumstances that render a marriage either void or voidable. These circumstances are outlined in N.C. Gen. Stat. § 51-3 and include:

• Bigamy: If one spouse was already legally married to another person at the time of the marriage, the subsequent marriage is considered void.
• Incest: Marriages between close relatives are prohibited by law and are considered void. This includes marriages between ancestors and descendants, siblings, and certain other close relatives. N.C. Gen. Stat. § 51-4 outlines the degrees of kinship that are prohibited.
• Lack of consent: If one spouse lacks the mental capacity to consent to the marriage, it may be considered voidable.
• Underage marriage: If one or both parties were under the legal age to marry and did not have proper parental or judicial consent, the marriage may be annulled.
• Impotence: If one spouse was physically incapable of consummating the marriage and the other spouse was unaware of this condition at the time of marriage, the marriage may be voidable.
• Fraud or duress: If one spouse was coerced into the marriage or if fraud was involved, it may be considered voidable.

Void vs. voidable marriages

Understanding the difference between void and voidable marriages is crucial when considering an annulment:

• Void marriages: A void marriage is considered invalid from the start. It’s as if the marriage never legally occurred, and no legal action is necessary to declare it void. However, obtaining a court declaration of annulment may still be necessary to resolve any legal issues that arise from the relationship.
• Voidable marriages: A voidable marriage is considered valid until it is annulled by a court. This means that either party can seek an annulment, but until the court grants the annulment, the marriage remains legally valid. Once annulled, the marriage is treated as though it never existed.

The annulment process in North Carolina

The process of obtaining an annulment in North Carolina involves filing a petition with the court and proving the grounds for annulment. Here’s an overview of the steps involved:

• Filing a petition: The spouse seeking the annulment must file a petition with the court outlining the grounds for annulment. This petition must include details about why the marriage is void or voidable.
• Serving the petition: The petition must be served to the other spouse, who has the opportunity to respond. If both parties agree to the annulment, the process may proceed more smoothly.
• Court hearing: A court hearing will be scheduled where both parties can present evidence and arguments. The judge will review the case and determine whether the grounds for annulment are valid.
• Court decision: If the judge grants the annulment, the marriage is declared void or voidable, depending on the circumstances. The marriage is then treated as though it never existed.

Children and annulled marriages

One of the common concerns in cases of annulment is the status of children born during the marriage. In North Carolina, children born during an annulled marriage are considered legitimate. This is outlined in N.C. Gen. Stat. § 50-11.1, which states that the legitimacy of children is not affected by the annulment of their parents’ marriage.

This means that even though the marriage is treated as if it never existed, the legal status of the children remains intact. They are entitled to the same rights and protections as children born in a valid marriage, including inheritance rights and the right to receive child support from both parents.

Key differences between legal separation, annulment, and divorce

Understanding the key differences between legal separation, annulment, and divorce is essential for making informed decisions about how to proceed with ending a marriage. Here’s a comparison of these three options:

	Legal Separation	Annulment	Divorce
Legal Status	Still legally married	Marriage is declared void or voidable	Marriage is legally dissolved
Grounds	No specific grounds required	Must meet specific statutory grounds	No-fault or fault-based grounds
Time Requirement	No minimum separation period required	No time requirement, but must prove grounds	Must be separated for at least one year
Property Division	Can be determined by separation agreement	Treated as though the marriage never existed	Divided according to equitable distribution laws
Spousal Support	Can be included in separation agreement	Generally not applicable	May be awarded as part of the divorce settlement
Child Custody	Can be determined by separation agreement	Determined separately from annulment	Determined as part of the divorce settlement
Children’s Legitimacy	Not affected	Children are legitimate (per N.C. Gen. Stat. 50-11.1)	Not affected
Benefits Retention	May retain benefits (e.g., health insurance)	N/A	Generally lost after divorce

When to choose legal separation or annulment

Choosing between legal separation, annulment, and divorce depends on your specific circumstances and goals. Here are some scenarios where legal separation or annulment might be more appropriate than divorce:

When legal separation is appropriate:

• Uncertainty about divorce: If you’re unsure whether you want to end your marriage permanently, legal separation allows you to live apart and make decisions about your future without the finality of divorce.
• Religious or moral beliefs: For couples who have religious or moral objections to divorce, legal separation provides an alternative that allows them to live apart without dissolving the marriage.
• Financial considerations: If you need to retain certain benefits, such as health insurance, legal separation can be a practical solution.

When annulment is appropriate:

• Void or voidable marriage: If your marriage falls under the specific circumstances that render it void or voidable according to North Carolina law, such as bigamy, incest, lack of consent, or fraud, seeking an annulment may be appropriate. An annulment can legally erase the marriage as if it never existed.
• Preserving legal clarity: For individuals who want to clarify their marital status for legal or personal reasons, especially if the marriage was entered into under fraudulent or coercive conditions, an annulment provides a clear resolution.
• Short duration of marriage: If the marriage was very short and did not produce children or involve significant assets, an annulment might be a simpler and more fitting option compared to divorce.

Implications and considerations

Each option—legal separation, annulment, and divorce—has its own set of legal implications and considerations. It’s essential to carefully evaluate these factors to determine which option best meets your needs.

Impact on property division

• Legal separation: Property division during legal separation is handled through a separation agreement, which can outline how assets and debts are to be divided. This can be particularly useful if you plan to divorce later, as the agreement can serve as a reference for the final divorce settlement.
• Annulment: Since an annulled marriage is considered never to have existed, there is no division of marital property. However, if property issues arise from the period of cohabitation before the annulment, they must be resolved separately.
• Divorce: Divorce involves equitable distribution of marital property and debts. The court will divide the assets and liabilities based on principles of fairness, considering factors such as the duration of the marriage, contributions of each spouse, and economic circumstances.

Spousal and child support

• Legal separation: Spousal support (also known as alimony) can be included in the separation agreement. Depending on the agreement between the spouses or court orders, this support can be temporary or permanent.
• Annulment: Alimony is generally not awarded in annulment cases because the marriage is considered to have never existed. However, financial support may still be arranged through other legal means if necessary.
• Divorce: Spousal support may be awarded based on factors such as the length of the marriage, the financial needs of the lower-earning spouse, and the ability of the other spouse to pay. Child support is also determined based on guidelines that consider the needs of the children and the income of both parents.

Children and custody

• Legal separation: Child custody and support are handled through a separation agreement. The terms of custody and visitation can be negotiated to ensure that the best interests of the children are met.
• Annulment: Children born during an annulled marriage are considered legitimate. Custody and support issues are handled separately from the annulment process and are resolved based on what is in the best interests of the children.
• Divorce: Custody and support arrangements are made based on the best interests of the children. The court may issue custody, visitation, and child support orders as part of the divorce decree.

Social and emotional considerations

• Legal separation: Offers a middle ground for couples who need time apart but may not be ready to make the final decision to divorce. It can provide stability and clarity while preserving the option to reconcile.
• Annulment: This can provide a sense of resolution and clarity if the marriage was entered into under invalid circumstances. It may also simplify legal and personal matters by formally addressing the invalidity of the marriage.
• Divorce: This represents a final end to the marital relationship and may involve more emotional and social adjustment. It’s essential to be prepared for the implications of a final dissolution of the marriage.

If you’re considering ending your marriage and are unsure whether legal separation, annulment, or divorce is the best path for you, Epperson Law Group is here to provide skilled guidance and support. Our experienced Charlotte family law attorneys help you understand your options, navigate the legal process, and make informed decisions that align with your goals. Contact us today to schedule a consultation and take the first step toward resolving your marital issues with confidence and clarity. Please call our office or submit our contact form to schedule a case evaluation today. Our team is located in Charlotte, Concord, Weddington, and Boone for your convenience.

 

META: Wondering if you can get a legal separation or annulment instead of a divorce? Talk to our Charlotte family law attorneys today.